Well, Josh needed time to think it over so off he went fishing. He took his small aluminum boat out into the bay and it wasn't 5 minutes later, when he got his first bite. He pulled his line in and found he had caught a nice-sized cod. As he was taking the hook out, the fish spoke to him:

Fish: "Please release me, let me go. I am the last of my species and if you put me back in the water, I will grant you a wish."

Josh thought for a second and then said, "I wish this here small boat of mine, was a small yacht just like Ben's."

The following day, Josh was found clinging to a buoy after the small yacht he was fishing in, sank from damage to its keel.